Submissions from Readers

Three years later and my sister has no movement.

by Rene'e
(Philadelphia PA)

Question My sister is 54 yrs old and started having problems with opening windows, jars, etc. She started losing muscle mass and now she's not able to walk or use her arms and hands, but she can move her head and wiggle her feet. She said she had a stroke and her nurse said it's ALS. She sleeps with oxygen at night. Is this condition reversible? I was told people can get ALS symptoms after having a stroke.


Answer: I would assume that the nurse would know your sister's diagnosis if she says she does (unless the nurse is telling you that's just her opinion). What you describe does sound like ALS, however, there are other neurologic conditions that can mimic ALS symptoms, but I'm assuming she has already been diagnosed by the doctor since the nurse is telling you that your sister has ALS. If she has not been diagnosed by a doctor, then you won't know what's wrong until she gets an official diagnosis.

What you describe does not sound like stroke. It's possible she could have both conditions, but a gradual loss of muscle mass, use of hands, and inability to move over time is not the pattern for a stroke. Strokes come on abruptly due to damage to the brain from either lack of blood flow (ischemic stroke) or bleeding (hemorrhagic stroke). ALS on the other hand is due to degeneration of neurons and at this time has no cure and is not reversible. It also is genetic in about 5-10% of cases. You can read more about ALS at https://www.ninds.nih.gov/Disorders/Patient-Caregiver-Education/Fact-Sheets/Amyotrophic-Lateral-Sclerosis-ALS-Fact-Sheet.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Stroke Rehabilitation Questions.


Stroke Rehab Guide      Exercises Included!   CLICK HERE

Get your stroke rehab questions answered by a therapist! CLICK HERE

Recent Articles

  1. Problems with frustration and with losing temper

    May 16, 18 09:36 PM

    Question: My partner had a stroke almost one year ago. He used to be a real go-getter, very active physically, and went non-stop. Now he has a hard time

    Read More

  2. Physically a vegetable

    May 09, 18 02:26 PM

    Question: My husband who is 61 years old has many, many health problems. Heart disease, kidney, liver disease, server brain atrophy, vascular issues,

    Read More

  3. Stroke Survivor Experiences

    May 09, 18 02:13 PM

    Read stories and get inspiration from stroke survivors.

    Read More

Share your stroke
treatment or exercise
recommendation.
Click Here

Share your stroke survival story - CLICK HERE!